Nintendo Fan Forum  

Go Back   Nintendo Fan Forum > Nintendo Corner > Member Game Reviews > Nintendo DS Reviews

Notices

Nintendo DS Reviews Section for all Nintendo DS and DSI Reviews

Comment
 
Review Tools
Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver review
Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver review
Again?
Published by da Beef
04-04-2010
Author review
GraphicsN/A
StorylineN/A
Controls/GameplayN/A
SoundN/A
Average N/A%
Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver review




"We are remaking an old game, but this is quite a challenge. Old fans would not want us to mess with their good memories... but there is no point in just redoing the same thing, right? We are working toward something that brings back memories, yet is also completely new!"


Encountering Game Freak's in-game avatars in the Celadon Condominiums is just as surreal as it was ten years ago, but the new text spoken by the company's President strikes me as disclaimer-ey bullshit. This may come off as fanboy ranting and nitpicking, but I call fair game. Some of the crap they pulled makes me wonder if the development team ever even played the original Gold and Silver.

For starters, a lot of the polygon-ization doesn't work. While the updated aesthetics are generally pleasant, too many of the 3D models are eyesores. Caves and cliffs are downright ugly, boulders are inconsistently split between pixel-based sprites and polygons, and Gyms resemble planet-sucking, parasitic spaceships. Speaking of the Gyms, I know these are video games and all (JRPGs at that), so arbitrary anachronisms come with the territory, but what is with the interior design of those places? It's not so much the art direction; anyone who's ever played an RPG in their lives is familiar with the overworld/interiors dichotomy; but rather the level design. In what was apparently an attempt to utilize the DS's processing power, each Gym now contains overproduced, pointlessly polygon-based puzzles. Plodding through these is tiresome and annoying -- keeping the old puzzles would have been more than fine. I'm just glad that Kanto and Johto still have their own tree sprites. If they didn't... then I don't know what.

Because that's really the whole point of these games: the contrast of two neighboring lands, each with their own unique culture, unified by those wondrous critters. Kanto is modern; every town brims with the mark of industry and the ease of technology. Celadon and Saffron are the largest cities in the game, and are kept alive by a nearby power plant, the only one in either region. Its importance is evident; until the player restores functionality to the plant, free travel between the regions is impossible, the Magnet Train unable to run without electricity. Perhaps the game's single best expression of Japan's urbanization comes when it is revealed that a family's home was demolished in favor of constructing one of the Magnet Train's stations. Kanto's resident Pokémon reflect this modernization, too: Grimer is said to excrete from industrial waste; Voltorb's discovery postdates the advent of the Poké Ball. Recall the fat man of Pallet Town, his text unchanged since Generation 1: "Technology is incredible!"

Johto is Kanto's illustrious mirror; Johto is historic. Heritage is celebrated everywhere. Buildings are traditionally Japanese, from their visual appearance to the inclusion of the code of etiquette; tiny shoe sprites, set off to the side, are visible in most homes. Ancient pagodas are also maintained in several towns, two of which are central to the game's story. All five of the original games' legendary Pokémon sprung from these towers. Fitting, because Johto's legendary Pokémon truly were just that; legendary. Tales of these creatures have been passed down for centuries, and are regarded with utmost reverence.

It's so saddening, then, that HeartGold and SoulSilver are not the consummate, all-encompassing Pokémon games that Gold and Silver were. The metaphor is barely intact now. In the original Gold and Silver, none of Kanto's legendary Pokémon were present. Their absence was never fully explained, but it perfectly personified Kanto's distance from its own history. Now all of Kanto's legendary Pokémon can be caught. Just as inexplicably, some Hoenn legendaries from Generation 3 have made their way into the game. This would have made much more sense if all of these new Pokémon resided in Johto rather than Kanto, then the beautiful juxtaposition of old and new would have remained, at least in some form. The lowest point of the entire game is the return of Viridian Forest. In Generation 1, Viridian Forest, besides being where Pikachu lived, was the nightmarish first "dungeon" of the game, prepping you for the tough Gym battle ahead. In Generation 2, upon discovering that Kanto was playable in this Generation as well, my heart leapt at the thought of nostalgically retreading familiar ground -- but the painful memories of Viridian Forest distressed the back of my mind. When I finally summoned the bravery to revisit that hellish grove, though, I was greeted with an incredible development: the forest had been cleared! Consistent with the ever-expanding Kanto, Viridian Forest was now nothing more than a few harmless patches of grass. I remember the music clearly: an ingenious remix of the original Viridian Forest theme, but after the first few disjointing chords, a brand new infectiously sweet melody took over, signifying the change. In HeartGold and SoulSilver, with the forest appearing as it did in Generation 1, the most grotesque retcon of all time has taken place. Both the meaning and my memories have been hacked away, but the remix (now a remix of a remix), only furthering the craziness, remains.

The real head-scratcher is the fact that all of this needless addition came at the expense of actual logical implementation, namely of some key features from Generation 3. Both that generation's berry and meme systems are in HeartGold in SoulSilver, but in a cripplingly limited fashion. Every fruit-bearing tree in the game is now an apricorn tree; there are no trees that produce berries on the overworld. This makes absolutely no sense, and is boring, lazy game design. Berries are now restricted to a key item, operational only through a menu. The meme system is really no more than a cameo reference. Remember those wacky, yet effortlessly profound NPC responses from Ruby, Sapphire, and Emerald? (some of my personal favorites: HAS DANCE, LIFE LESSONS, STOCK PRICES) Yeah, they're gone. But it's more cool this way. The more legendaries and useless features a Pokémon game has, the better. All in the name of fan-service, right?

It is so strange to think that in a little more than a decade, a weird RPG about bug-catching on the Game Boy, glitchy as hell and full of poor localization (did it ever occur to anyone how racist the name Porygon is, or why there exist female Mr. Mime?), has become the behemoth that we know it today. What many surely wrote off as a cultural oddity and no more than the latest marketing phenomenon, was for many kids of the right age, a way of life. But at the core of the cult, before the anime and the trading cards and the mountains of merchandise, there was a handful of great video games. The Gold and Silver versions were for a lot of fans the best the series ever got, and Nintendo's lowest common denominator remakes bank more on nostalgia than anything else. Indeed, on the whore, these remakes are about the worst that they could have been... but damned if I haven't already put 80 hours into my adventure. It's painfully obvious that these games came more out of necessity than passion; it makes sense for Nintendo to want every single Pokémon available in a single generation, so the magic of the original Gold and Silver isn't really there... but most of the fun is. It's still Pokémon, and I will always, always love Pokémon.

"If you treat your Pokémon nicely, they will love you in return."

LIFE LESSONS, people. LIFE LESSONS.
Published by
Banned
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 3,038
Rep Power: 0
da Beef will become famous soon enoughda Beef will become famous soon enough
Sponsored Links
  #1  
By SuperGamecube64 on 04-04-2010, 01:25 PM
originally, I was going to reserve Soul Silver. i began my Pokemon "Career", ironically, on my 10th birthday with silver...for those that don't get it, Pokemon Trainer's generally start at 10, so I find that funny. anyway, i eventually decided I'd just get the game later, but now, I'm really not sure...so many of my memories rest within that clocked out old cartridge with a dead save battery and a partially torn sticker...do I really want to take the chance of ruining them? perhaps they are better off staying as they are...memories. At the same time though, I just can't help but want to get my hands on it.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
By Cam3ron36@NFF on 04-04-2010, 02:39 PM
Only RPG's that I really like anymore are these pokemon games. Of course I had Red & Blue as a kid since my Brothers each bought one and eventually handed them off to me, still though. I have played Red, Blue & Pearl and loved all of them but if I'm going to play Gold and silver, then it will be on a GBC emulator.
Reply With Quote
  #3  
By da Beef on 04-04-2010, 03:05 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by SuperGamecube64 View Post
originally, I was going to reserve Soul Silver. i began my Pokemon "Career", ironically, on my 10th birthday with silver...for those that don't get it, Pokemon Trainer's generally start at 10, so I find that funny. anyway, i eventually decided I'd just get the game later, but now, I'm really not sure...so many of my memories rest within that clocked out old cartridge with a dead save battery and a partially torn sticker...do I really want to take the chance of ruining them? perhaps they are better off staying as they are...memories. At the same time though, I just can't help but want to get my hands on it.

i know how you feel. like i pointed out, theres a lot of stupid shit in the these remakes, but... it's so... addicting...
Reply With Quote
  #4  
By AlloftheAbove on 04-04-2010, 10:10 PM
If you take what SuperGamecube64 said, and replaced the age of 10 to the age of 11, you'd have my exact post. Creepy.

Anyway, a very good review. Could use some screenshots, though.
Reply With Quote
  #5  
By Cam3ron36@NFF on 04-04-2010, 11:27 PM
I think 6 or 7 for me so I have you both beat

Edit: then again, my first was Blue... Or was it Red?
Reply With Quote
  #6  
By Keyman4 on 04-05-2010, 12:10 AM
This is a great great game and is one of the best Pokemon games to date

I like the graphical style and how you can hear your footsteps when running, running water, etc.

A very detailed review....kudos?
Reply With Quote
  #7  
By Pokeman on 04-05-2010, 02:06 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by keyman4 View Post
This is a great great game and is one of the best Pokemon games to date

I like the graphical style and how you can hear your footsteps when running, running water, etc.

A very detailed review....kudos?
hearing your footsteps isn't even close to being new.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
By Keyman4 on 04-17-2010, 06:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pokeman View Post
hearing your footsteps isn't even close to being new.

Well I never heard the footsteps in previous games and I said I like them, not mentioning they're new
Reply With Quote
Comment


Currently Active Users Viewing This Review: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Review Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off


Similar Threads
Review Review Starter Category Comments Last Post
The Rom for Pokemon B&W(JP). Final Flourish Nintendo DS/DSI/3DS 0 09-25-2010 02:05 PM
Pokemon Black & White TheLoveB4U Nintendo DS/DSI/3DS 62 09-17-2010 10:42 PM
HeartGold/SoulSilver Jade Nintendo DS/DSI/3DS 74 04-29-2010 01:20 PM
HeartGold and SoulSilver release date. Xenon Gaming News 25 01-11-2010 03:18 PM
House of The Dead 2 & 3: Return Review Skreamo Nintendo Wii Reviews 13 10-21-2008 01:09 PM

NFF Youtube Videos NFF Facebook page

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:53 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.3
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

Review powered by GARS 2.1.9 ©2005-2006
Nintendo Blog

Nintendofanforum.com is a Nintendo fansite and is not associated with or endorsed by Nintendo of America, Inc.
All trademarks and images belong to their respective owners.
Nintendo Wii